Well you know what they say about trilogies: the third installment is always the best in the series, right?

Look up the first and second installments of my unselected New Yorker Cartoon Caption Contest submissions here and here.

I had two ideas for this cartoon; I submitted the top one. What do you think, should I have submitted the one below instead?

… as in new moon … which is in shadow… I know, if you have to explain it…